MLB Starting Lineups, Pitcher Statistics and Odds for July 16, 2026
Thursday’s post-All-Star-break schedule features a nationally televised National League East matchup between the New York Mets and Philadelphia Phillies.
New York Mets at Philadelphia Phillies
Game Odds
+112
-132
+124
-148
+139
-143
A full-game run line and total were not available in the supplied odds report at publication time. Moneyline prices may continue to move before the first pitch.
Starting Pitcher Comparison
Christian Scott
New York Mets · Right-Handed Pitcher
12
12
54.0
3.17
1.30
27.9%
11.2%
30.1%
1.2
10.8
4.3
2.5
Aaron Nola
Philadelphia Phillies · Right-Handed Pitcher
19
19
97.0
5.75
1.43
24.0%
7.3%
39.4%
1.9
9.5
2.9
4.66
Expected Starting Lineups
New York Mets
- CFA.J. Ewing — L
- LFJuan Soto — L
- 3BBo Bichette — R
- SSFrancisco Lindor — S
- RFCarson Benge — L
- DHJorge Polanco — S
- 1BJared Young — L
- 2BBrett Baty — L
- CFrancisco Alvarez — R
Philadelphia Phillies
- SSTrea Turner — R
- DHKyle Schwarber — L
- 1BBryce Harper — L
- LFBrandon Marsh — L
- 3BAlec Bohm — R
- 2BBryson Stott — L
- CJ.T. Realmuto — R
- RFGabriel Rincones Jr. — L
- CFJustin Crawford — L
Pitching and Lineup Analysis
Christian Scott enters the matchup with the stronger surface-level run-prevention profile. The Mets right-hander has recorded a 3.17 ERA through 12 starts and 54 innings while striking out 27.9 percent of the batters he has faced. His 10.8 strikeouts per nine innings demonstrate legitimate swing-and-miss ability, but his 11.2 percent walk rate and 4.3 walks per nine remain areas of concern.
Scott has produced only a 30.1 percent ground-ball rate, leaving him dependent on strikeouts and manageable fly-ball contact. His 1.2 home runs allowed per nine innings is not extreme, although pitching in a power-friendly Philadelphia environment against a lineup featuring Kyle Schwarber and Bryce Harper presents a demanding test.
Aaron Nola has made 19 starts and logged 97 innings, but his 5.75 ERA and 1.43 WHIP reflect an uneven first half. Nola continues to generate strikeouts at a solid rate, recording a 24.0 percent strikeout percentage and 9.5 strikeouts per nine innings. His 7.3 percent walk rate is considerably lower than Scott’s, allowing him to limit some of the damage caused by hard contact.
Nola’s 4.66 FIP is listed because it is more than one full run below his 5.75 ERA. That difference indicates that his results have been worse than several defense-independent indicators would ordinarily project. Home runs remain the central issue, however, with Nola allowing 1.9 per nine innings and posting a 16.5 percent home-run-to-fly-ball rate.
The expected Mets lineup is heavily left-handed and switch-hitting. Juan Soto, Carson Benge, Jared Young and Brett Baty provide left-handed looks, while Francisco Lindor and Jorge Polanco can bat from either side. That construction may place immediate pressure on Nola’s ability to keep the baseball in the park.
Philadelphia counters with a balanced order led by Trea Turner, Schwarber, Harper, Brandon Marsh and Alec Bohm. Scott’s elevated walk rate could become costly against a Phillies lineup capable of extending plate appearances and creating run-scoring opportunities without relying exclusively on hits.
The Pick
Free MLB Picks For Today 7/16/2026
MLB Sharp Betting Card
New York Mets vs Philadelphia Phillies
Play: Philadelphia Phillies Moneyline
Moneyline: -128
Grade: B+ (Home-split advantage)
Key Edges:
Featured Analysts & Cappers
Read free daily matchup breakdowns and track documented betting records.
- Philadelphia owns the stronger home offensive profile, batting .254 with a .441 slugging percentage.
- New York has struggled offensively on the road, hitting .230 with a .374 slugging percentage.
- The Mets enter with a 19-29 road record, creating a clear situational disadvantage.
- Philadelphia has won 32 of 52 home games and has consistently protected Citizens Bank Park.
- Christian Scott’s elevated 11.2% walk rate could create traffic against a patient Phillies lineup.
- Aaron Nola’s 4.66 FIP sits well below his 5.75 ERA, pointing toward potential positive regression.
- Both bullpens are rested, reducing the bullpen-fatigue risk behind Philadelphia.
Read:
Philadelphia has the better lineup split, stronger home efficiency and more reliable situational profile. Nola remains volatile, but the Phillies’ offensive and home-field edges justify laying a manageable moneyline price.

